I reckon this proves some part of the show is rigged! They just did this to get the save out of the way and they used it on somebody 95% of people won't disagree with. After last year's fiasco with Casey, I dislike the save, they should axe it for next year.
I think the show has lost a LOT of credibility for this. There's no way in HELL Jessica and Joshua were in the bottom 3 for real
Elise was the only one they got right.
I went whaaaaaaaaat when it happened. Holly should have been in the bottom 3 and maybe Skylar too, or perhaps Philip.
I loled at the judges crashing the stage during Jessica's performance
And Jennifer's face when Jessica was announced as having to sing
Either America doesn't know talent from their asses or it's rigged.
My opinion on who's left:
Philip - He has a good voice, but he's coasting along, and needs to ramp it up or risk elimination.
Colton - He's hot
He can do all sorts of styles, and he has a great voice. He's a dark horse contender.
Joshua - Uber talented, but he won't win.
Skylar - Boring. Her voice is kinda painful to listen to IMO, and the country songs are getting dull.
Jessica - One of the best voices they've had on Idol to date, she can sing anything.
Elise - Meh, she's alright. Good voice, but her attitude is kinda annoying and I didn't think her You And I performance was that great.
Holly - I reckon she should have gone this week. She's got a good voice, but she can't control it properly.