Moderators: Amir, kingofskiffle, seattleboy, arab, AutomaticBR
The problem stemps from the chart as printed on 4 June 1966Chartnutz wrote:You might find this a little hard to agree with, but I think something odd happened in the MM chart in early June of 1966. My theory is that Sandie Shaw's "Nothing Comes Easy" and Crispian St. Peters' "Pied Piper" traded places in the chart for some reason.
Here's my evidence - the chart positions for both these records in all the major charts of the time, starting on May 28 1966:
Nothing Comes Easy:
------------------
MM : 30-16-22
NME: 18-15-16-17-22
RR : 25-14-14-16-17-24
DISC: 27-17-14-13-17-24
BBC: ??-14-14-15-17
Pied Piper:
----------
MM : 15-15-10-15-17-25
NME: 15-16-26
RR : 13-16-21
DISC: 14-15-25-28
BBC: 15-15
Although the charts never fully agree on anything much, MM was virtually never out of line with the others to this extent. "Pied Piper" was on the way down the charts after having reached a high of #5 a couple of weeks earlier, so MM's reversal of direction from 15 to 10 is highly unusual and not reflected anywhere else. More importantly, an average of the 4 industry charts doesn't compute to the BBC chart shown.
I am proposing that the chart positions for the two singles should be:
Nothing Comes Easy
------------------
MM : 30-16-10-15-17-25
Pied Piper
----------
MM : 15-15-22
This fits the overall trajectories of the other charts and taking an average of the 4 charts does in fact create the BBC chart shown.
I'd be curious to know if anyone has any information that can back up my theory.
I used the last week positions of 27 September chartasm wrote:Must admit i'm puzzled how Andrej compiled chart of 20 Sept 69 as it is still missing!
The first chart wasn't published, it's made up from the 'Last Week' positions of the following week, which was the first week published.BrainDamageII wrote:WOW thanks for that. Missing positions on first chart? Can anyone fill them in.
Thanks for spotting those.ridersinthesky wrote:Hi, have some corrections to MM'S 60s charts:
1/8 August 1964: Nos.49/48 Inez & Charlie Foxx - Happiness (Sue) (title obviously mixed up with Ken Dodd's Happiness)was actually Inez Foxx - Hurt By Love
(record was credited to Inez Foxx only)
13/20/27 February 1965: Nos. 45/45/44 I think the record listed was 'Laugh, Laugh' by Beau Brummels released on Pye Int. early February 1965 (a US Top 20 hit from January 1965).