Exactly! Mariah was brilliant live for 7 years of her career. She was good again in 2003/04 and the start of 05! There is so much ignorance being spoken in this thread and the word "opinion" is being used as a cover up!frisbee wrote:I'm sorry but this, in reality, doesn't come down to opinion. Judging Vocal ability is not subjective at all - a reason why only a handful of contestants make through X factor auditions.TIfan wrote:^^^^^ IMO both Beyonce and Christina are more talented than Mariah handsdown. Mariah has them on songwriting but when it comes to live singing, both B and Xtina have giving some live vocal performances that put Mariah to shame. IMO of course.
This was for a 04wayne comment that disapperared I guess...
I will have to completely disagree that Beyonce or Christina are better. Mariah started to absolutely suck live (save an one-off brilliant performance now and then) but the first 5-6 years of her career were pure, invaluable gold.
I just can't at people saying that Beyonce and Christina are more talented vocalists than MARIAH CAREY!