Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Madonna :: Charts & Sales History

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by upushme View Post
    Youtube 24.04.2022

    1) La Isla Bonita (Official Video) 570,205,683 +361,870
    2) Hung Up (Official Video) [HD] 363,385,844 +177,578
    3) Frozen (Official Video) [HD] 140,650,483 +140,000
    4) Material Girl (Official Video) [HD] 105,359,198 +127,484
    5) Like A Prayer (Official Video) 211,189,799 +116,852
    6) Frozen (Fireboy DML Remix) [Official Music Video] 7,426,779 +91,122
    7) Papa Don't Preach (Official Video) [HD] 172,098,374 +72,038
    8) 4 Minutes feat. Justin Timberlake & Timbaland (Official Video) 165,404,526 +65,537
    9) The Power Of Good-Bye (Official Video) 54,997,859 +39,321
    10) Don't Cry For Me Argentina (Official Video) 28,801,474 +33,353
    Love #9 and #10, but also love how out of place they seem compared to the rest.

    Comment


    • Originally posted by music126 View Post

      Love #9 and #10, but also love how out of place they seem compared to the rest.
      Don't Cry For Me Argentina was Madonna's biggest hit since Vogue back then worldwide. I just feel it's her own fanbase that keeps undermining the song.
      It did crazy numbers and it was a #1 hit at the Hot 100 in Europe, her first since Vogue i think...and the #8 biggest european hit at their year-end charts from 1997.

      I'm sure her numbers from south america much be huge as well.
      "Your actions speak louder than promises/You're inclined to make and inclined to break"

      Comment


      • Hot Dance/Electronic Songs

        https://www.billboard.com/charts/dan...ctronic-songs/

        12 (11) 20 Frozen - Madonna vs. Sickick (Peaked #10)

        Dance/Electronic Digital Song Sales

        https://www.billboard.com/charts/dan...al-song-sales/

        14 (10) 20 Frozen - Madonna vs. Sickick (Peaked 05)
        Madonna is The most successful and influential female artist of all time.

        Comment


        • Madonna Vs Sickick's "Frozen" (Fireboy DML Remix) Music Video 7.5Million
          Madonna is The most successful and influential female artist of all time.

          Comment


          • Originally posted by TiagoRodrigues View Post

            Don't Cry For Me Argentina was Madonna's biggest hit since Vogue back then worldwide. I just feel it's her own fanbase that keeps undermining the song.
            It did crazy numbers and it was a #1 hit at the Hot 100 in Europe, her first since Vogue i think...and the #8 biggest european hit at their year-end charts from 1997.

            I'm sure her numbers from south america much be huge as well.

            No and No and No!
            "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" was huge and important in Europe, especially on sales, but it wasn't exaclty like that!

            As an Airplay Hit "Erotica", "Rain", "Secret", "You'll See" and other 90's songs were still bigger than DCFMA in Europe in the 90's.



            Madonna #01 Hits on European Hot 100 Sales during the 90's:


            "Vogue" was #01 for 8 weeks on European Hot 100 in 1990
            European Year End Sales 1990 Chart #02 (It was #07 airplay song for 1990 on European Year End Airplay)
            (In 1990 "Hanky Panky" was #89 on European Hot 100 Sales Year End Chart and #24 for Year End Airplay for 1990)

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1990-12-22.pdf

            "Erotica" was #01 for 3 weeks on European Hot 100 in late 1992 ("Erotica" was also #01 on European Hot 40 Airplay for 4 weeks - EDITED AND CORRECTED not 3 weeks).
            European Year End Sales for 1992 Chart #45 (It was only released in October spending 8 weeks on charts)
            On European Hot Airplay Year End Chart 1992 was only at #39 (It was only released in October spending 9 weeks on charts). On the date of Year End Issue both "Erotica" and "Deeper and Deeper" songs were inside European Hot 100 TOP 40. Also "Erotica" was still at #16 on the weekly airplay despite "Deeper and Deeper" already be #09 on airplay chart as well that week.

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1992-12-19.pdf


            "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" was #01 for 2 weeks on European Hot 100 in early 1997 (peaked #02 for 2 weeks on European Hot 40 Airplay)
            European Year End Chart Sales for 1997 #08
            On European Hot Airplay Year End Chart 1997 was only at #33 (it spent only 12 weeks on Airplay TOP 40)

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1997-12-27.pdf

            ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

            "Justify My Love" peaked #03 on European Hot 100 (peaked #23 on Hot 100 Year End Chart 1991 while "Rescue Me" was #90 that year too).
            Sales and airplay for this song were split in 1990 and 1991 (peaked #37 on Year End Airplay Chart while "Rescue Me" was #67 that year too)
            On 1990 year end issue weekly chart the song was #08 on Weekly Airplay TOP 25 (2 weeks on chart) and #04 on Hot 100 (2 weeks on chart).

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1991-12-21.pdf

            "This Used To Be My Playground" peaked #02 on European Hot 100 weekly chart for multiple weeks and #01 on European Airplay Chart.

            It was #14 on European Hot 100 Year End Chart and #02 on Year End European Airplay Chart 1992

            This is from the same year "Erotica" was also a Year End TOP 40 European Airplay Hit as well.

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1992-12-19.pdf


            Still during the 90's Madonna did have a few big Hot 100 Hits that never reached to #01 - "Secret" was the higest from '93 to '96 peaking #04 in 1994 (and #47 on Year End Chart - "Secret" #34 on Year End European Airplay Chart).
            "Secret" was released later on the year only spending 8 weeks on the charts during 1994 and a few more weeks during 1995 (unlike "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" that spent all its weeks but 1 on the charts during 1997 only).

            "You'll See" peaked at #08 on European Hot 100 but had enough longevity to appear on Year End Charts at #83 in 1995 and at #74 in 1996 (as it was release late on the year). It's late year release (like "Secret") didn't help the song on the Year End Charts.

            There were other songs, despite only reaching TOP 20 on European Hot 100, spent a lot of weeks on the charts and were still big airplay hits (like "Rain" that was a bigger airplay hit in Europe than "Don't Cry For Me Argentina").

            Certainly DCFMA was very important as was her first #01 on European Hot 100 in 4 years (and first Year End TOP 10 Best Seller since "Vogue") but #01's and Year Ends are not always the most important. "Frozen" went to be quite bigger despite never reaching #01 on European Hot 100.

            "Frozen" was even the biggest #02 ever on European Hot 100 as "Frozen" spent 16 weeks at #02 behind Celine Dion "My Heart Will Go On" that spent an all time record 17 weeks at #01 !!!! "Frozen" was #01 on European Airplay for multiple weeks!

            On Year End European Hot 100 Sales "Frozen" was #05 and on Year End European Airplay was #03! Even "Ray of Light" song that peaked #09 on European Hot 100 and #93 on Year End Hot 100 was #18 on Year End European Airplay Chart (so higher than DCFMA).

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1998-12-19.pdf

            Later during that decade later both "The Power of Goodbye" and "Beautiful Stranger" peaked #02 on European Hot 100 as well. Before that "Justify My Love"

            About "Rain"...

            In Europe Madonna "Rain" was huge - despite missing the TOP 10 European Hot 100 Sales Chart peaking at #15 stayed 5 weeks inside the TOP 20 and 11 weeks inside the TOP 40 - it was #96 on Year End European Hot 100 of 1993 barely making the Year End Chart on Sales but...

            "Rain" was still a big radio hit entering at #20 (2nd highest entry with Billy Joel "River of Dreams" entering at #19 that week) and jumping to #05 on European Hot 100 airplay chart on 2nd week (Billy Joel climbed to #06 that same week). It ended up peaking #04 for 2 non-consecutive weeks on European Hot 40 Airplay Chart.

            "Rain" spent 14 weeks on TOP 40 Airplay chart:

            #19 - #05 - #05 - #04 - #05 - #04 - #08 - #10 - #11 - #14 - #22- #29 - #37 - Out

            On Year End 1993 European Radio Chart "Rain" was #25 Song (and #15 on Year End European AC Radio).

            https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1993-12-18.pdf

            "Rain" was big enough to make "Erotica" album re-enter the European TOP 100 Albums in 21 August 1993 at #98 climbing to #89 the following week before dropping again out of the TOP 100.
            Last edited by MadNuno; Wed April 27, 2022, 04:53.

            Comment


            • Streams on Spotify 25/04/2022

              Frozen (Sickick Remix) 54,930,752 (+361,929)

              Fireboy DML Version 3,447,029 (+44,320)

              070 Shake Version 2,465,428 (+59,429)

              Total 465,678 daily streams
              Madonna is The most successful and influential female artist of all time.

              Comment


              • It is possible to reply without writing a college thesis paper. Reading all of that still proves his point that DCFMA was in fact her first number 1 since Vogue.

                Comment




                • Monthly Listeners

                  21.983.915 ( + 12.457 )

                  #147 overall


                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by jjavier1978 View Post
                    Streams on Spotify 25/04/2022

                    Frozen (Sickick Remix) 54,930,752 (+361,929)

                    Fireboy DML Version 3,447,029 (+44,320)

                    070 Shake Version 2,465,428 (+59,429)

                    Total 465,678 daily streams
                    Monday update, along the sunday ones, are always the worst!!

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Angeman View Post
                      It is possible to reply without writing a college thesis paper. Reading all of that still proves his point that DCFMA was in fact her first number 1 since Vogue.
                      No that's incorrect. DCFMA was Madonna's first number 1 since Erotica (not Vogue).

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Angeman View Post
                        It is possible to reply without writing a college thesis paper.

                        true tho

                        Comment




                        • Best selling international western female albums in Japan


                          1.Mariah Carey - Number Ones - 3.7 million
                          2.Whitney Houston - The Bodyguard - 3 million
                          3.Mariah Carey - Daydream - 2.8 million
                          4.Mariah Carey - Merry Christmas - 2.8 million
                          5.Mariah Carey - Music Box - 2.4 million
                          6.Enya - Paint the Sky with Stars - 2.1 million
                          7.Celine Dion - All The Way A Decade Of Song - 2.1 million
                          8.Tatu - 200 km wrong lane - 2 million
                          9.Avril Lavigne - Let Go - 1.8 million
                          10.Celine Dion - Lets Talk About Love - 1.6 million
                          11.Mariah Carey - Butterfly - 1.5 million
                          12.Celine Dion - The Colour Of My Love - 1.4 million
                          13.Lauryn Hill - The Misseducation of Lauryn Hill - 1.3 million
                          14.Madonna - Like A Virgin - 1.25 million
                          15.Celine Dion - Falling Into You - 1.2 million
                          16.Cyndi Lauper - Twelve Deadly Cyns and Then Some - 1.2 million
                          17.Madonna - The Immaculate Collection - 1.135 million
                          18.Avril Lavigne - Under My Skin - 1.125 million
                          19.Enya - A Day Without Rain - 1.1 million
                          20.Enya - Themes from Calmi Cuori - 1.1 million
                          21.Avril Lavigne - The Best Damn Thing - 1.08 million
                          22.Madonna - True Blue - 1.05 million
                          23.Enya - The Memory Of Trees - 1.05 million
                          24.TLC - Fanmail - 1.05 million
                          25.Mariah Carey - Emotions - 1.025 million
                          26.Lady Gaga - The Fame Monster - 1.015 million
                          27.Britney Spears - Greatest Hits My Prerogative - 1 million
                          28.Whitney Houston - Whitney Houston - 1 million
                          29.Mariah Carey - Mariah Carey - 1 million
                          30.Mariah Carey - Rainbow - 1 million


                          Most Entries
                          Mariah Carey - 8
                          Enya & Celine Dion - 4
                          Madonna & Avril Lavigne - 3
                          Whitney Houston - 2

                          from Haven

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by Angeman View Post
                            It is possible to reply without writing a college thesis paper. Reading all of that still proves his point that DCFMA was in fact her first number 1 since Vogue.
                            That post was chart related, and it contained some interesting chart facts, if u think it’s too long and that bothers u, simply scroll down

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Angeman View Post
                              It is possible to reply without writing a college thesis paper. Reading all of that still proves his point that DCFMA was in fact her first number 1 since Vogue.
                              Go read it again...

                              "Erotica" was #01 on European Hot 100 for 3 weeks in 1992... and also #01 on European Airplay for 4 weeks (DCFMA was only #02 on airplay).


                              On Airplay in Europe at least other 7 songs were way MORE successful than DCFMA in Europe after Vogue and before "Frozen"
                              Last edited by MadNuno; Wed April 27, 2022, 04:55.

                              Comment


                              • Airplay doesn't mean much when it comes to determining what was a hit and what was not. Radios can plan some songs a lot but if people don't buy them or choose to listen to them (in the 90's streaming wasn't measured so only sales were decisive back then), they're hardly big hits.

                                Eurochart was based on the points system, not real sales, so I would also take it with a pinch of salt even though I used to love that chart.
                                "DCFMA" was a big hit indeed but calling "Rain" huge when it hardly reached any Top 10's is a big exaggeration. It was a minor success, if anything.

                                Comment


                                • Originally posted by MadNuno View Post


                                  No and No and No!
                                  "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" was huge and important in Europe, especially on sales, but it wasn't exaclty like that!

                                  As an Airplay Hit "Erotica", "Rain", "Secret", "You'll See" and other 90's songs were still bigger than DCFMA in Europe in the 90's.



                                  Madonna #01 Hits on European Hot 100 Sales during the 90's:


                                  "Vogue" was #01 for 8 weeks on European Hot 100 in 1990
                                  European Year End Sales 1990 Chart #02 (It was #07 airplay song for 1990 on European Year End Airplay)
                                  (In 1990 "Hanky Panky" was #89 on European Hot 100 Sales Year End Chart and #24 for Year End Airplay for 1990)

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1990-12-22.pdf

                                  "Erotica" was #01 for 3 weeks on European Hot 100 in late 1992 ("Erotica" was also #01 on European Hot 40 Airplay for 3 weeks as well).
                                  European Year End Sales for 1992 Chart #45 (It was only released in October spending 8 weeks on charts)
                                  On European Hot Airplay Year End Chart 1992 was only at #39 (It was only released in October spending 9 weeks on charts). On the date of Year End Issue both "Erotica" and "Deeper and Deeper" songs were inside European Hot 100 TOP 40. Also "Erotica" was still at #16 on the weekly airplay despite "Deeper and Deeper" already be #09 on airplay chart as well that week.

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1992-12-19.pdf


                                  "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" was #01 for 2 weeks on European Hot 100 in early 1997 (peaked #02 for 2 weeks on European Hot 40 Airplay)
                                  European Year End Chart Sales for 1997 #08
                                  On European Hot Airplay Year End Chart 1997 was only at #33 (it spent only 12 weeks on Airplay TOP 40)

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1997-12-27.pdf

                                  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

                                  "Justify My Love" peaked #03 on European Hot 100 (peaked #23 on Hot 100 Year End Chart 1991 while "Rescue Me" was #90 that year too).
                                  Sales and airplay for this song were split in 1990 and 1991 (peaked #37 on Year End Airplay Chart while "Rescue Me" was #67 that year too)
                                  On 1990 year end issue weekly chart the song was #08 on Weekly Airplay TOP 25 (2 weeks on chart) and #04 on Hot 100 (2 weeks on chart).

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1991-12-21.pdf

                                  "This Used To Be My Playground" peaked #02 on European Hot 100 weekly chart for multiple weeks and #01 on European Airplay Chart.

                                  It was #14 on European Hot 100 Year End Chart and #02 on Year End European Airplay Chart 1992

                                  This is from the same year "Erotica" was also a Year End TOP 40 European Airplay Hit as well.

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1992-12-19.pdf


                                  Still during the 90's Madonna did have a few big Hot 100 Hits that never reached to #01 - "Secret" was the higest from '93 to '96 peaking #04 in 1994 (and #47 on Year End Chart - "Secret" #34 on Year End European Airplay Chart).
                                  "Secret" was released later on the year only spending 8 weeks on the charts during 1994 and a few more weeks during 1995 (unlike "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" that spent all its weeks but 1 on the charts during 1997 only).

                                  "You'll See" peaked at #08 on European Hot 100 but had enough longevity to appear on Year End Charts at #83 in 1995 and at #74 in 1996 (as it was release late on the year). It's late year release (like "Secret") didn't help the song on the Year End Charts.

                                  There were other songs, despite only reaching TOP 20 on European Hot 100, spent a lot of weeks on the charts and were still big airplay hits (like "Rain" that was a bigger airplay hit in Europe than "Don't Cry For Me Argentina").

                                  Certainly DCFMA was very important as was her first #01 on European Hot 100 in 4 years (and first Year End TOP 10 Best Seller since "Vogue") but #01's and Year Ends are not always the most important. "Frozen" went to be quite bigger despite never reaching #01 on European Hot 100.

                                  "Frozen" was even the biggest #02 ever on European Hot 100 as "Frozen" spent 16 weeks at #02 behind Celine Dion "My Heart Will Go On" that spent an all time record 17 weeks at #01 !!!! "Frozen" was #01 on European Airplay for multiple weeks!

                                  On Year End European Hot 100 Sales "Frozen" was #05 and on Year End European Airplay was #03! Even "Ray of Light" song that peaked #09 on European Hot 100 and #93 on Year End Hot 100 was #18 on Year End European Airplay Chart (so higher than DCFMA).

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1998-12-19.pdf

                                  Later during that decade later both "The Power of Goodbye" and "Beautiful Stranger" peaked #02 on European Hot 100 as well. Before that "Justify My Love"

                                  About "Rain"...

                                  In Europe Madonna "Rain" was huge - despite missing the TOP 10 European Hot 100 Sales Chart peaking at #15 stayed 5 weeks inside the TOP 20 and 11 weeks inside the TOP 40 - it was #96 on Year End European Hot 100 of 1993 barely making the Year End Chart on Sales but...

                                  "Rain" was still a big radio hit entering at #20 (2nd highest entry with Billy Joel "River of Dreams" entering at #19 that week) and jumping to #05 on European Hot 100 airplay chart on 2nd week (Billy Joel climbed to #06 that same week). It ended up peaking #04 for 2 non-consecutive weeks on European Hot 40 Airplay Chart.

                                  "Rain" spent 14 weeks on TOP 40 Airplay chart:

                                  #19 - #05 - #05 - #04 - #05 - #04 - #08 - #10 - #11 - #14 - #22- #29 - #37 - Out

                                  On Year End 1993 European Radio Chart "Rain" was #25 Song (and #15 on Year End European AC Radio).

                                  https://worldradiohistory.com/UK/Mus...1993-12-18.pdf

                                  "Rain" was big enough to make "Erotica" album re-enter the European TOP 100 Albums in 21 August 1993 at #98 climbing to #89 the following week before dropping again out of the TOP 100.
                                  You could've just said "Erotica was her previous #1 in Europe, not Vogue". But even if Erotica was also #1 you proved my point...DCFMA was her biggest song in Europe since Vogue. Your list proves it as well
                                  "Your actions speak louder than promises/You're inclined to make and inclined to break"

                                  Comment


                                  • Originally posted by maroon View Post
                                    Airplay doesn't mean much when it comes to determining what was a hit and what was not. Radios can plan some songs a lot but if people don't buy them or choose to listen to them (in the 90's streaming wasn't measured so only sales were decisive back then), they're hardly big hits.

                                    Eurochart was based on the points system, not real sales, so I would also take it with a pinch of salt even though I used to love that chart.
                                    "DCFMA" was a big hit indeed but calling "Rain" huge when it hardly reached any Top 10's is a big exaggeration. It was a minor success, if anything.
                                    I know it's based on points... not real sales or real spins or airplay audiences as well.

                                    I said "Rain" was a bigger airplay hit than DCFMA in Europe - it was not in any mean a hit as big as DCFMA. Still radio airplay was always important (especially before the 2000's as more people listened to radio).

                                    I would say "This Used To Be My Playgroud" was as big (or bigger) than DCFMA in Europe despite peaking #02 on European Hot 100 (just like "Frozen" was clearly bigger despite peaking at #02 as well).

                                    TUTBMP was the #14 Best Selling Single in Europe in 1992 (based on points) and #02 Most Played Song on European Radios that year (It was the song that had more stations playing, more stations in A rotation of the year and the longest #01 airplay of the year as it was #01 for 8 weeks on airplay). During the 90's everybody used to listen to the radio. One of the reasons it was not even a bigger airplay hit and haven't had even better sales was the release of the single "Erotica" shorting TUTBMP radio life and store exposure.

                                    DCFMA was #08 best selling single in Europe in 1997 (based on points) and only #33 Most Played on European Radios that year. There was not a following single cutting it from the radios. The song remix did help the single to sell well as it was not available in any Album being exclusive from the single. And the movie EVITA was also a big advertisement since it was very successful and mediatic at the time.

                                    TUTBMP had no remix played on radios or clubs and despite not being available in any Madonna album was on the compilation "Barcelona Gold" that was a big seller in Europe during 1992. Later the song certainly helped a bit her ballads collection STR to sell as it was the first time the song was included in a Madonna album.

                                    In 1992 the only song more played on the European Radios than TUTBMP was Geroge Michael "Too Funky" (but he was #19 on Hot 100 European Year End Sales Chart while TUTBMP was #14 on Hot 100 European Sales). This shows how big TUTBMP really was at the time (and comparing to DCFMA).

                                    I agree that sales are more important than airplay but in 1992 Madonna spent 12 weeks at #01 on European Airplay Chart being the artist that spent more weeks at #01 on that chart that year and was the #02 Airplay Artist of the year (George Michael was #01 as also had 2 TOP 40 Airplay Hits) while in 1997 Madonna was not even a TOP 20 Airplay Artist as her only song to chart on the year end chart was DCFMA at #33!

                                    Madonna was again #02 airplay artist in 1998 as "Frozen" was #03 Airplay Hit of the Year and "Ray of Light" was the #18 airplay hit of the 1998 and "Drowned World" was the #55 song (the "Power of Goodbye" was released later and was inside the TOP 10 Airplay Chart on the Year End Issue!)

                                    Madonna was #01 on airplay chart for 13 weeks in 1998 (also the most for any artist that year as it happened in 1992 but 1 more week at #01). In 1998 she also did bit better in European Hot 100 Sales than in 1992 as well too.
                                    Last edited by MadNuno; Wed April 27, 2022, 05:42.

                                    Comment


                                    • Originally posted by Forreal View Post

                                      That post was chart related, and it contained some interesting chart facts, if u think it’s too long and that bothers u, simply scroll down
                                      scrolling down is hard to do with such long posts and when people quote the post it just makes the page messy. Thats why long posts arent always the best.

                                      Comment


                                      • Please don't quote long posts guys, just quote the part you're responding to.

                                        Comment


                                        • The fact that many people listened to the radio in the 90s doesn't have anything to do with what was or was not a hit, at least not in my understanding of this term. Airplay promotes the music, just like music channels do or used to do. What they choose to playlist and finds listeners/viewers is one thing, however only what people DECIDE to purchase, stream or vote for can actually represent the public interest. The fact I heard a song a million times doesn't mean that I like it so throwing any airplay data in here when talking about what was or wasn't a hit is like comparing apples to pears in my opinion.

                                          Having said that, I agree that "TUTBMP" was a big hit (not only in Europe), probably comparable with "DCFMA".

                                          Comment


                                          • I think this is a very tricky question ,especially when you put songs in the context of time.
                                            Justify My Love was indeed huge but it's far from being known or popular now a days.
                                            Don't even get me started on This used to be my playground.
                                            I don't know a single person who knows it.
                                            So,you either use their original peak position to say how big they were back then or use streaming to adjust its popularity to the present day.
                                            The only thing I'm sure is that you can't use a song's peak when they were released 30 yrs ago to say how big they are now.

                                            Comment


                                            • Originally posted by BodyShop View Post
                                              I think this is a very tricky question ,especially when you put songs in the context of time.
                                              Justify My Love was indeed huge but it's far from being known or popular now a days.
                                              Don't even get me started on This used to be my playground.
                                              I don't know a single person who knows it.
                                              So,you either use their original peak position to say how big they were back then or use streaming to adjust its popularity to the present day.
                                              The only thing I'm sure is that you can't use a song's peak when they were released 30 yrs ago to say how big they are now.
                                              It have everything to do with people age.

                                              I literally know dozens of non Madonna fans that know TUTBMP but most are all over 40yo as they were 10yo already at that time (most they know the song because it played a lot on the radio). We were discussing how much of a hit the songs were when released.

                                              I agree with you that a song being an HIT 30 years ago doesn't make it an HIT or Known by general public NOW.

                                              Over 90% of the songs that were Hits in the past are not Hits now and most younger people don't know them yet older people remember them and are still expose to them. Older songs only become known to younger people if they get somehow expose to them (Wide Audience Live performances, younger artists covers, TV Shows or Movies having those songs, Viral social media content with the song).

                                              TUTBMP still plays at 90's radio hit stations/shows and music channels and people that were alive in 1992 and paying attention to music certainly remember the song for sure. The songs was never performed live by Madonna and despite being on a 1992 movie was never ever promoted again (maybe some radios did pick it up a bit again in '95/'96 on Hit shows due to STR compilation, but not much) - after 30 years no new promotion was made for this song so it's only natural that it faded and it's completely unknown to a everyone under 40/45yo.

                                              Comment


                                              • Album: The Immaculate Collection
                                                iTunes:
                                                #32 Australia (NE)
                                                #58 United Kingdom (+31)
                                                Madonna is The most successful and influential female artist of all time.

                                                Comment


                                                • Madonna is The most successful and influential female artist of all time.

                                                  Comment


                                                  • Monthly Listeners

                                                    ​​​​​​- 4565

                                                    21.979.350

                                                    still #147 overall

                                                    Comment

                                                    Working...
                                                    X