The Ultimate Averaged Chart - The BBC Chart Re-Imagined

[MrTibbs]

Greetings Pop Pickers !

Welcome to my new thread.

Back in 1958 the BBC chose to compile it's own chart by averaging out the charts from the published music papers of the day.
I believe the principle of doing so was sound as an averaged chart compiled from these music papers ironed out any discrepancies and extremes from any individual chart thus giving a more meaningful chart.

However beyond this principle unfortunately the methodology used was weak and was inconsistent. The BBC used a strange method of awarding points to chart positions, 1 point for a No 1, 2 points for a No 2 and so on down the chart to 20 points for a No 20 then later 30 points for a No 30. However this led to many tied positions within their chart. Also the BBC awarded 21 points then later 31 points to all records for all records falling outside a chart which was unfair as obviously all records outside the chart could not hold this position equally therefore giving inaccurate data. Also this method assumed all charts were equal, but they were not as each paper used a different number of store returns to compile their chart so obviously all charts were not equal in the amount of data they used for chart compilation. By January 1964 MM was using around 250 store returns but RR by comparison was using around 85. NME was around 200 and Disc around 100.

Furthermore, once compiled the chart was not thoroughly checked for accuracy as it came to light that some calculations were erroneous leading to some inaccurate charts which were never corrected.
All of this was a pity, because this was the chart that was broadcast on Pick Of The Pops and Top Of The Pops until February 1969 and was therefore accepted by millions as the chart of choice that they grew up with.

So, I have gone back to basics to correct these weaknesses and produce a much more reliable 'averaged chart' to compile a chart not only based on Inverse Points but also factoring in the the number of Store Returns that the Music Papers used for chart compilation to produce a much more reflective, accurate, balanced, and consistent chart. I will post these here as I compile them and as an added bonus will add the positions of each of the music papers used and also the BBC chart to give a full picture in one graph displaying history for all to see.

So, finally to the methodology.

All records in every Top 30 will qualify for a chart position.
Each record for starters will be allocated points based on the 'Inverse Points' basis, 30 for a No 1 down to 1 point for a No 30.
Then points based on proportion of Record Store Returns used by each Music Paper will be factored in. Alan Smith (ASM) did considerable research into this number of store returns so I have chosen to use his reliable research as the basis for my calculations.
EP's in the earlier years were placed in all the charts except those compiled by RR. To overcome this I took an average of the MM, NME and Disc positions if the EP charted on all three and awarded this to RR to ensure consistency.
For split sides in NME where both sides are placed close in the chart I have discounted the NME chart position and I again have taken an average of the other charts and awarded this to NME. Where the split side is a considerable distance apart in NME, eg, one side in the top ten and the other at the bottom end of the top twenty or further, I have used the higher chart position.
For the No 1 position where one record has most points but another tops most charts see post #1364 for a detailed explanation as to how #1 is determined.
On the rare occasion should a tie occur at any position this will be broken by the store used with the highest number of store returns.

I am going to start in January 1964 as that was when I bought my first records after watching Top Of The Pops, till 1969, then do 1960 to 1963, then the fifties.

So on with the show ! Enjoy, and feel free to let me know what you think of the first chart about to be posted. Brian.

[Splodj]

Looks good.

I agree with not including the RR 31-50 as they were pretty unreliable at this time.

Narrower chart position columns on the right would help with my view of it on a tablet. Also I would like to see the Top 30, then a separating row before the also rans - but this is just a personal preference.

[Splodj]

What about LPs? I notice that 'With the Beatles' is 24, but 14 in the BBC composite.

[Splodj]

Me again. I don't think you should put the average EP position in the RR column as it is not applicable to the RR chart, just a part of your overall calculation to prevent EPs scoring less than they should.

[Blondini]

The BBC used a method of awarding inverse points, 1 point for a No 1, 2 points for a No 2 and so on down to 20 points for a No 20 then later 30 points for a No 30.

Each record for starters will be allocated points based on the 'Inverse Points' basis, 30 for a No 1 down to 1 point for a No 30.

I'm confused.

[MrTibbs]

Thanks for the feedback guys. I am taking this on board. I am narrowing the columns for the next spreadsheet. On the draft it looked as though it would fit but when posted it overshot sorry about that. I will repost 4th January again if you want as I have now adjusted the columns for that too.
Yes I will insert a row after the 30 to differentiate from the lower positions. I did not use the RR 31 to 50 positions for the reasons you gave Splodj. As the Beatles album was included in two of the original charts I felt it fair to include it as that was how it was at the time. Because the BBC treated all charts equally the Beatles came out at 14 in the BBC chart by the way they averaged it on points. Because I have factored in the music papers and MM had the biggest sample and didn't chart albums this dropped it to a more realistic position in the rankings.
Yeah I needed to add the EP position to the RR chart in the spreadsheet for the rankings Splodj, but I should have removed them when I posted here but I have now and corrected the chart above.
Blondini, Hi, The BBC for tallying their points used a strange system of awarding 1 point for a No 1, 2 points for No 2, 3 for a 3 and so on down the chart. I am using the more traditional method of 30 points for No 1, then 29 points for No 2, and so on down to 1 point for No 3, then factoring in the record store returns per Music Paper chart to provide a much more robust chart.
Don't be too hard on me guys lol this was my first attempt with the spreadsheet and stats.

[MrTibbs]

The Ultimate Averaged Chart - Week Ending January 4th 1964							BBC	NME	RM	MM	Disc	RR
Last	This						Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart
Week	Week	Title and Artist						Total Chart Positions				30
1	1	I Want To Hold Your Hand - The Beatles					1	1		1	1	1
2	2	Glad All Over - The Dave Clark Five					2	2		2	2	2
3	3	She Loves You - The Beatles					3	3		3	3	3
4	4	Dominique - The Singing Nun					6=	5		4	7	7
7	5	I Only Want To Be With You - Dusty Springfield					5	4		7	5	6
6	6	You Were Made For Me - Freddie and The Dreamers					4	8		5	4	4
8	7	Twenty Four Hours From Tulsa - Gene Pitney					6=	6		6	6	5
5	8	Secret Love - Kathy Kirby					8	7		8	8	9
11	9	Swinging On A Star - Big Dee Irwin					9	9		9	12	11
21	10	Hippy Hippy Shake - The Swinging Blue Jeans					10	9		12	10	13
9	11	Maria Elena - Los Indios Tabajaras					11	11		11	15	8
14	12	I Wanna Be Your Man - The Rolling Stones					13	12		10	16	15
10	13	Don't Talk To Him - Cliff Richard					12	12		14	11	10
12	14	Geronimo - The Shadows					15	14		13	20	12
13	15	Twist And Shout (EP) - The Beatles					16	17		16	13	15
16	16	You'll Never Walk Alone - Gerry and The Pacemakers					18	16		15	18	16
15	17	Kiss Me Quick - Elvis Presley					17	15		19	14	14
20	18	Chris Sandford - Not Too Little Not Too Much					19	22		18	19	18
24	19	Stay - The Hollies					21	18		21	28	17
17	20	The Beatles Hits (EP) - The Beatles					20	19		24	17	20
18	21	I'll Keep You Satisfied - Billy J Kramer and The Dakotas					22	23		20	21	21
23	22	We Are In Love - Adam Faith					23	21		22	24	20
29	23	Money - Bern Elliot and The Fenmen					24	26		17		19
19	24	All I Want For Christmas Is A Beatle - Dora Bryan					25	27		23	27	24
22	25	It's Almost Tomorrow - Mark Wynter					26	24		25	25	30
26	26	Do You Really Love Me Too - Billy Fury					28	25		29	22
25	27	If I Ruled The World - Harry Secombe					27			26	26	22
27	28	I (Who Have Nothing) - Shirley Bassey					29			28		25
NEW	29	What To Do - Buddy Holly								27		28
NEW	30	At The Palace - Wilfrid Brambell and Harry H Corbett					30=	28				26
		Do You Hear What I Hear - Bing Crosby					30=				23
		Blue Bayou / Mean Woman Blues - Roy Orbison										23
		Country Boy - Heinz									29	27
		Hungry For Love - Johnny Kidd and The Pirates						30		30
		The Beatles No 1 (EP) - The Beatles						29
		From Russia With Love - Matt Monro										29
		I'm In Love - The Fourmost									30
		With The Beatles (LP) - The Beatles						20			9

[Woz1234]

Country Boy by Heinz was at #27 in Record Retailer that week, Good chart.

[Blondini]

It was the way you described both methods as "inverse points" when only the second corrected method is inverse. The BBC method was not.
No matter. Keep it up.

[Splodj]

I suppose the BBC system could be called the corresponding points method. It is a bit of a red herring because there is no inherent difference between it and the inverse points method.

TOTP spread the idea of the chart to a lot of people who had not been particularly interested in pop music hitherto, so I think this is a good week to start.

[Graham76man]

I sort of think this is a good idea. It would have been really good if the BBC chart was a well known chart. But apart from when it was TOTP at the time, it's never become an iconic chart and is rarely published. So what you are doing is probably reproducing a new chart for the 60's in many ways.
One thing I would say about any point based chart is the size is limited to whatever the smallest chart is. So as NME never went over 30. You can only have an accurate top 30. Even if some of the charts were 100 strong. Which for a time a 100 was produced in one of the papers. The reason you need to stick to a 30 is that some records will start to cue to get into the 30, the bigger you make the chart. Due to the top 31 to 100 slots being not common to all charts. And it's likely that some records would follow a pattern in the charts, if the charts were all the same size. For example a record might enter at 49 move to 37 and then 32 before entering the top 30. And this would be repeated with the odd variation on every chart.
For this reason if I were doing them I would produce a top 30 and have the rest as numbered breakers. Even if a record was going down.

Not certain how you figure the numbers of shops used to a points figure? That too could produce a cue in places even in the 30. Since the Melody Maker has the most shops it will tend to dominate the 30 and as it became a 50 a low new entry could make the 30.
Rather like the Official chart when it was just downloads. I-tunes having all the chart slots and the rest of the sellers having no effect in it's charts.

[Metalweb]

I suppose the BBC system could be called the corresponding points method. It is a bit of a red herring because there is no inherent difference between it and the inverse points method.

TOTP spread the idea of the chart to a lot of people who had not been particularly interested in pop music hitherto, so I think this is a good week to start.

Surely there is an inherent difference.....the treatment of records not in the chart/s.

The inverse points system is so much more logical I'm amazed the BBC never thought of it....

[MrTibbs]

NME was a Top 30 at this time, as was DISC, MM was predominantly also a Top 30 although it flirted with a Top 50 off and on briefly so it made sense to keep this chart to a Top 30 too but including and giving chart positions to all records that made a Top 30. Much more accurate as it was well known that positions 31 to 50 were unreliable in RR as we're MM who also had the row over hyping in their 31 to 50 positions. So it is a Top 30 but with the records falling outside this numbered from 31 to show their relative positioning.

The store numbers do make a difference but not as much as you would think. If you look at the first chart above the differences by and large are subtle but effective. Whereas the BBC treated all charts equally it has long been argued here and wider that MM and NME were the charts using the larger sample so it is right to see that represented in the chart of charts. I am using Alan Smith's researched data for this and not just a figure from my head. As with my previous thread I want these charts to be as accurate as possible with all the information we have and are likely to have.

Keep enjoying and watch the new averaged chart unfold telling the real story of the time with inconsistencies ironed out and balance restored. With no way of knowing accurate sales figures for this period I believe this is the best chance we will ever have to reflect how an all encompassing chart of the time should have looked.

[Splodj]

The corresponding points system may have tempted them to award 21 points to outsiders, but with a bit more consideration they could have awarded the actual 21-30 positions - which is why I maintain there is no inherent difference, just that the corresponding points system is more likely to lead you astray.

With regard to LPs, wouldn't it be better to have them either completely in (a la BBC) or completely out? Out would be my preference, as the NME ended up being the only one to include them.

[Woz1234]

With The Beatles (LP) - The Beatles.

20

9

Was "With The Beatles" (LP) still #14 in the BBC Chart?

[trebor]

Please do not quote full charts! Thank you

[Graham76man]

...it was well known that positions 31 to 50 were unreliable in RR as we're MM who also had the row over hyping in their 31 to 50 positions. So it is a Top 30 but with the records falling outside this numbered from 31 to show their relative positioning.
...With no way of knowing accurate sales figures for this period I believe this is the best chance we will ever have to reflect how an all encompassing chart of the time should have looked.

Actually Brian I have compiled the top 100 from 1965 and 1966 and I am currently doing the 1967 charts, which of course use sales and not points and take out fiddles. Though to be honest at this period the fiddles were not to bad. I have come across more fiddles doing the 2000 charts! I have marked up the known none entries with a red colour on the Word files I use and compared with the RR 50 from the 60's there are more on the 75 than the 50. Since what was often being fiddled was selling anyway. Just not in the few hundred stores these charts used. I have documented the big hype of Jeff Beck's - Hi Ho Silver Lining, which even got into the 30's selling under 7,000. Not enough to put it in the 100! While the Attack's version was ignored by the other charts and made the top 20! Beck's hype being the thing that triggered the reduction of the top 50 to 30 on the Melody Maker chart, probably! The 1965 chart features the last Woolworth's Embassy records, which had become EP's by this point. Link to the charts below.

https://therealchart.blogspot.com/p/...0s-charts.html

Apart from the LP's on the above charts "At The Palace - Wilfrid Brambell and Harry H Corbett" Would also be excluded not for being hyped, but being all "talk". It's just a recording of Steptoe and Sons!

I would have done the 1964 charts, but the release dates information on 45 Cat was very poor at the date I started doing the 60's chart. So it was best to start in 1965. Prior to 1963 records were still issued on the month, as in the Missing Charts book 1940-52. But from 1963 onwards they went weekly on a Friday. But even in 1964 dates were patchy. Even if the dates were good now. It couldn't be done to get a full list of what was released each week. As some stupid idiot at 45 Cat decided to cut results in the search from 100 to just 50 - this year! Making it impossible to get full results.

[MrTibbs]

Yeah Roadie it was, but somehow got deleted from the spreadsheet grrrr. I have re-entered it. Thanks for picking that up.

[MrTibbs]

OK guys here is the next chart for 11th January, I have altered the bottom end to just give music paper positions for the records that did not make the Top 30, this allows better focus on the actual Top 30 and improves the overall layout. The records that were outside last week's Top 30 you will note are treated as New Entries in the actual Top 30 this week.
What is interesting is that whilst totally removing joint positions, factoring individual store returns just makes subtle changes to the chart compared to the BBC chart so dispels the suspicion that the largest returns by MM would dominate in it's favour. So all in all a well balanced chart I would say and minus ties.

The Ultimate Averaged Chart - Week Ending January 11th 1964							BBC	NME	RM	MM	Disc	RR
Last	This						Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart
Week	Week	Title and Artist						Total Chart Positions				30
2	1	Glad All Over - The Dave Clark Five					1=	2		1	1	2
1	2	I Want To Hold Your Hand - The Beatles					1=	1		2	2	1
10	3	Hippy Hippy Shake - The Swinging Blue Jeans					3	3		3	3	3
5	4	I Only Want To Be With You - Dusty Springfield					4	5		4	5	4
7	5	Twenty Four Hours From Tulsa - Gene Pitney					5	4		5	4	6
3	6	She Loves You - The Beatles					6	6		6	6	5
9	7	Swinging On A Star - Big Dee Irwin					7	7		8	8	8
6	8	You Were Made For Me - Freddie and The Dreamers					8	8		9	7	7
4	9	Dominique - The Singing Nun					9	9		7	9	10
8	10	Secret Love - Kathy Kirby					10	10		10	10	9
12	11	I Wanna Be Your Man - The Rolling Stones					11	11		11	12	12
19	12	Stay - The Hollies					12	11		12	13	11
17	13	Kiss Me Quick - Elvis Presley					13	13		14	11	15
11	14	Maria Elena - Los Indios Tabajaras					14	15		13	14	13
13	15	Don't Talk To Him - Cliff Richard					15	14		15	17	14
16	16	You'll Never Walk Alone - Gerry and The Pacemakers					16	18		17	15	17
14	17	Geronimo - The Shadows					18	19		16	19	18
22	18	We Are In Love - Adam Faith					17	20		18	16	16
15	19	Twist And Shout (EP) - The Beatles					19	16		19	20
26	20	Do You Really Love Me Too - Billy Fury					20	17		22	18	20
20	21	The Beatles Hits (EP) - The Beatles					22	22		20	24
18	22	Not Too Little Not Too Much - Chris Sandford					21	23		23	21	19
23	23	Money - Bern Elliot and The Fenmen					23	24		21	22	23
27	24	If I Ruled The World - Harry Secombe					25	26		25	25	21
21	25	I'll Keep You Satisfied - Billy J Kramer and The Dakotas					26	28		24	28	22
NEW	26	I'm In Love - The Fourmost					27	25			23
NEW	27	Hungry For Love - Johnny Kidd and The Pirates					28	29		28		24
29	28	What To Do - Buddy Holly					29=			26		27
30	29	At The Palace - Wilfrid Brambell and Harry H Corbett								27		25
NEW	30	Baby I Love You - The Ronettes					29=	26			27
		Beatles No 1 (EP) - The Beatles						30		29
		Country Boy - Heinz								30		26
		I (Who Have Nothing) - Shirley Bassey										28
		Don't Blame Me - Frank Ifield									29
		As Usual - Brenda Lee										29
		Poison Ivy - The Paramounts									30
		It's Almost Tomorrow - Mark Wynter										30
		With The Beatles (LP) - The Beatles					24	20			26

[MrTibbs]

Here is the next chart for 18th January 1964. It's proving very interesting. Just take a look at how close it actually is to the BBC chart. So the additional store returns are smoothing it out and fine tuning the average chart without causing major disruption. I'm liking this.

The Ultimate Averaged Chart - Week Ending January 18th 1964							BBC	NME	RM	MM	Disc	RR
Last	This						Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart
Week	Week	Title and Artist						Total Chart Positions				30
1	1	Glad All Over - The Dave Clark Five					1	1		1	1	1
2	2	I Want To Hold Your Hand - The Beatles					2=	3		2	3	2
3	3	Hippy Hippy Shake - The Swinging Blue Jeans					2=	2		3	2	3
5	4	Twenty Four Hours From Tulsa - Gene Pitney					4	4		4	4	6
4	5	I Only Want To Be With You - Dusty Springfield					5	5		5	5	4
7	6	Swinging On A Star - Big Dee Irwin					6	6		6	6	7
6	7	She Loves You - The Beatles					7	7		7	8	5
12	8	Stay - The Hollies					8	8		8	7	8
8	9	You Were Made For Me - Freddie and The Dreamers					9	10		9	11	9
9	10	Dominique - The Singing Nun					10	12		10	9	10
11	11	I Wanna Be Your Man - The Rolling Stones					11	9		12	12	14
13	12	Kiss Me Quick - Elvis Presley					12	11		11	13	15
18	13	We Are In Love - Adam Faith					13	13		15	10	13
10	14	Secret Love - Kathy Kirby					14	15		13	14	12
20	15	Do You Really Love Me Too - Billy Fury					15	16		14	17	17
NEW	16	I'm The One - Gerry and The Pacemakers					16=	13		22	15	23
NEW	17	As Usual - Brenda Lee					16=	17		20	20	16
NEW	18	Don't Blame Me - Frank Ifield					19	18		21	16	19
14	19	Maria Elena - Los Indios Tabajaras					18	27		16	19	11
15	20	Don't Talk To Him - Cliff Richard					20	20		17	25	21
16	21	You'll Never Walk Alone - Gerry and The Pacemakers					21	22		18	23	20
NEW	22	Needles And Pins - The Searchers					22	18		25	18	26
19	23	Twist And Shout (EP) - The Beatles					23	24		23	24
17	24	Geronimo - The Shadows					24	30		19	26	22
26	25	I'm In Love - The Fourmost					25=	21		27	21
30	26	Baby I Love You - The Ronettes					27	22		30	22	27
22	27	Not Too Little Not Too Much - Chris Sandford					25=			24	27	18
23	28	Money - Bern Elliot and The Fenmen					28			26		24
24	29	If I Ruled The World - Harry Secombe					29			29	28	25
NEW	30	Whispering - Nino Tempo and April Stevens						25
		The Beatles Hits (EP) - The Beatles					30			28	29
		The Rolling Stones (EP) - The Rolling Stones						28
		5 4 3 2 1 - Manfredd Mann						29
		I Think Of You - The Merseybeats						30			30
		Hungry For Love - Johnny Kidd and The Pirates										28
		Louie Louie - The Kingsmen						30
		Buddy Holly - What To Do										29
		At The Palace - Wilfrid Bramble and Harry H Corbett										30
		Say It Isn't So - Frank Ifield						26

[Metalweb]

Country Boy by Heinz was at #27 in Record Retailer that week, Good chart.

How old was Heinz when he died?

Sorry, completely off topic but couldn't resist one of my favourite pub quiz questions....

[Robbie]

How old was Heinz when he died?

Sorry, completely off topic but couldn't resist one of my favourite pub quiz questions....

I must admit I had to look up how old he was when he died but given your post I had a feeling I knew what the answer would be..!

[MrTibbs]

The Ultimate Averaged Chart - Week Ending January 25th 1964							BBC	NME	RM	MM	Disc	RR
Last	This						Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart
Week	Week	Title and Artist						Total Chart Positions				30
1	1	Glad All Over - The Dave Clark Five					1	1		1	2	1
3	2	Hippy Hippy Shake - The Swinging Blue Jeans					2	2		2	1	2
2	3	I Want To Hold Your Hand - The Beatles					3	3		3	3	3
4	4	Twenty Four Hours From Tulsa - Gene Pitney					4	7		4	4	5
5	5	I Only Want To Be With You - Dusty Springfield					5	6		5	7	4
22	6	Needles And Pins - The Searchers					6	4		9	6	6
16	7	I'm The One - Gerry and The Pacemakers					7	5		8	5	10
8	8	Stay - The Hollies					9	8		6	8	12
6	9	Swinging On A Star - Big Dee Irwin					8	9		7	9	7
7	10	She Loves You - The Beatles					13=	14		10	13	8
18	11	Don't Blame Me - Frank Ifield					11=	11		12	12	13
17	12	As Usual - Brenda Lee					10	10		15	11	9
13	13	We Are In Love - Adam Faith					11=	16		11	10	11
15	14	Do You Really Love Me Too - Billy Fury					13=	15		13	14	17
12	15	Kiss Me Quick - Elvis Presley					15	18		14	17	14
11	16	I Wanna Be Your Man - The Rolling Stones					16	17		17	15	15
25	17	I'm In Love - The Fourmost					17	12		19	18	21
9	18	You Were Made For Me - Freddie and The Dreamers					19	20		16	19	20
10	19	Dominique - The Singing Nun					18	21		18	16	16
NEW	20	5 4 3 2 1 - Manfred Mann					21	12		26	22	27
14	21	Secret Love - Kathy Kirby					20	24		20	21	18
26	22	Baby I Love You - The Ronettes					22	24		22	20	23
NEW	23	The Rolling Stones (EP) - The Rolling Stones					23	19		25	24
19	24	Maria Elena - Los Indios Tabajaras					24	29		21	29	19
NEW	25	The Dave Clark Five (EP) - The Dave Clark Five					25	28		24	25
20	26	Don't Talk To Him - Cliff Richard					26	23		28	30	26
23	27	Twist And Shout (EP) - The Beatles					27	30		23	28
NEW	28	Louie Louie - The Kingsmen						22
21	29	You'll Never Walk Alone - Gerry and The Pacemakers					28			27		22
30	30	Whispering - Nino Tempo and April Stevens					30	26			26
		I Think Of You - The Mersybeats					29			29	23	29
		Geronimo - The Shadows								30		24
		Not Too Little Not Too Much - Chris Sandford										25
		If I Ruled The World - Harry Secombe									27	30
		Money - Bern Elliot and The Fenmen										28
		Sat It Isn't So - Frank Ifield						27

[MrTibbs]

The Ultimate Averaged Chart - Week Ending February 1st 1964							BBC	NME	RM	MM	Disc	RR
Last	This						Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart	Chart
Week	Week	Title and Artist						Total Chart Positions				30
6	1	Needles And Pins - The Searchers					1	1		1	1	1
2	2	Hippy Hippy Shake - The Swinging Blue Jeans					2	2		2	2	3
1	3	Glad All Over - The Dave Clark Five					3	3		3	3	2
7	4	I'm The One - Gerry and The Pacemakers					4	4		4	4	4
4	5	Twenty Four Hours From Tulsa - Gene Pitney					5	5		5	5	7
3	6	I Want To Hold Your Hand - The Beatles					6	6		6	6	6
5	7	I Only Want To Be With You - Dusty Springfield					7	7		8	9	5
8	8	Stay - The Hollies					8	8		7	8	8
11	9	Don't Blame Me - Frank Ifield					10	8		10	10	10
12	10	As Usual - Brenda Lee					9	10		11	7	9
9	11	Swinging On A Star - Big Dee Irwin					13	12		9	13	12
13	12	We Are In Love - Adam Faith					11	13		12	11	11
20	13	5 4 3 2 1 - Manfred Mann					12	10		14	12	14
10	14	She Loves You - The Beatles					15	18		13	15	16
14	15	Do You Really Love Me Too - Billy Fury					14	16		17	14	13
17	16	I'm In Love - The Fourmost					17	15		15	17	20
NEW	17	I Think Of You - The Merseybeats					18	20		16	16	19
15	18	Kiss Me Quick - Elvis Presley					16	22		18	21	15
NEW	19	Diane - The Bachelors					19	14		24	18	22
16	20	I Wanna Be Your Man - The Rolling Stones					20	22		21	19	17
22	21	Baby I Love You - The Ronettes					21	25		19	23	18
23	22	The Rolling Stones (EP) - The Rolling Stones					22	19		29	20
19	23	Dominique - The Singing Nun					23			20	24	24
21	24	Secret Love - Kathy Kirby					24			23	25	21
28	25	Louie Louie - The Kingsmen					28	17			27
NEW	26	For You - Rick Nelson					25=	20			22	30
30	27	Whispering - Nino Tempo and April Stevens					27	26		26	26	26
18	28	You Were Made For Me - Freddie and The Dreamers					25=			22		25
24	29	Maria Elena - Los Indios Tabajaras					30			25	30	23
NEW	30	Candy Man - Brian Poole and The Tremeloes						24			29
		The Dave Clark Five (EP) - The Dave Clark Five					29	28		28
		If I Ruled The World - Harry Secombe								27		28
		Song Of Mexico - Tony Meehan						27
		Twist And Shout (EP) - The Beatles								30	28
		My Baby Left Me - Dave Berry						29
		You'll Never Walk Alone - Gerry and The Pacemakers										27
		Don't Talk To Him - Cliff Richard						30
		Geronimo - The Shadows										29

[Splodj]

When I try to recreate the BBC chart I get 6 records in different positions:

11 Big Dee Irwin (46 points) BBC-13
12 Adam Faith (47 points) BBC-11
13 Manfred Mann (50 points) BBC-12

16 Fourmost (67 points) BBC-17
17 Merseybeats (71 points) BBC-18
18 Presley (76 points) BBC-16

This could have been caused by only two mistakes - demoting Irwin and promoting Presley.

[Splodj]

And yes Brian I did notice that the positions my calculations put them in are the same as in your chart!