No announcement yet.

Legislation proposed in the UK that would force celebrities to declare when photos are airbrushed - good idea or not?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Legislation proposed in the UK that would force celebrities to declare when photos are airbrushed - good idea or not?

    Photo is of Dr Luke Evans, the MP who's proposed this legislation.


    Lawmaker fears celebrities are fueling a mental health crisis.

    We’ve all seen a celebrity or influencer’s Instagram post and knew almost immediately that it was edited in some way — either to improve their skin or hide some cellulite. A lot of these people are called out for pulling such stunts and perpetuating a beauty standard that can be harmful to some young girls.

    In 2019, internet sensation Dan Bilzerian was caught editing rapper Cardi B’s stomach to make it appear slimmer than it actually is. Khloe Kardashian was accused by many of Photoshopping a selfie to make her face seem thinner and her nose more shapely (in another Photoshop fail, she somehow ended up with one too many fingers on her left hand).

    There are countless other examples of Photoshop being used to alter people’s appearances — and while it might be unethical and send a wrong message to people, it’s not necessarily illegal — at least for now.

    Dr. Luke Evans, a member of the British Parliament and a general practitioner, has proposed a law that would require heavily edited posts from social media stars and advertisers to be labeled as such.

    Evans, speaking to the British tabloid The Sun, said celebrities have a “responsibility not to mislead young.” He further states such heavily edited posts create a warped sense of beauty and are fueling a mental health crisis.

    He’s not entirely wrong — various studies have shown that women look at their bodies negatively compared to those they see on social media. One study conducted by the Florida House Experience, a healthcare institution, found that 50% of women and 37% of men compare their bodies unfavorably to those they see on social media.

    The National Eating Disorder Association, which seeks to create awareness of eating disorders and provide resources to those struggling with one, warns against exposing children to such content because it might cause them to lose unnecessary amount of weight.

    In an effort to battle body image issues, Instagram already allows users to report posts they believe promote weight-loss products and cosmetic procedures to those under 18. In that case, Instagram either removes the post or restricts minors from seeing them.

    Labeling heavily edited photos would be another great step toward creating a more body-positive environment on Instagram — we’re all for people tracking weight loss and physique goals on social media, as it can be a great way to motivate people. But it also needs to be done properly and in a way that doesn’t lead to further harm.
    It's worth noting that this MP - Dr Luke Evans - is both a parliamentarian and a trained doctor, he's not some unqualified dimwit who's had a rise to power on the back of "BreXIt WilL mAKe the Uk GREAt aGaiN" or whatever.

    He's stated that celebrities have a responsibility not to mislead the young and that such a misconstrued sense of beauty is currently fuelling a mental health crisis - very valid points! I'm just not sure where you'd even begin to start on legislating something like this.
    Great idea, would be a good start on tackling a promiment issue
    Good idea, but wouldn't have much impact if implemented
    Terrible idea, he doesn't know what he's talking about
    Other view (specify in topic)

  • #2
    interesting take on the issue of how airbrushed lifestyle & pictures on social networks can drive people into depression
    Waffles are checked cookies