Madonna

[Artoo]

Listening to MDNA and I still don’t understand why you all hate it. There’s definitely a strong album in there.

[Westen]

Listening to MDNA and I still don’t understand why you all hate it. There’s definitely a strong album in there.

[beredy]

Listening to MDNA and I still don’t understand why you all hate it. There’s definitely a strong album in there.

I've been saying that ever since the album came out.

[Artoo]

I have always adored it. Is it her best? No. Is it her worst? Not when LAP exists. I definitely prefer it to RH too.

[Artoo]

The biggest problem with MDNA is that she needed a lead single she could perform at The Super Bowl... and the best songs are not suitable for that event or lead single material.

My top 5:

Girl Gone Wild
Gang Bang
Beautiful Killer
I ****ed Up
Love Spent

[BodyShop]

For me ,MDNA is ,by miles and miles her absolute worst.

[spiritboy]

To say LAP is worse than MDNA is a blasphemy

[AlphaMale]

I also listened to MDNA yesterday I I loved it more now than when it got released. I still think it has very good songs on it and was full of potencial.
No, it's not better than Like a Prayer. Not in this lifetime. Not in your dreams. No way!

[AlphaMale]

For me ,MDNA is ,by miles and miles her absolute worst.

Although initially I said RH was way better than mdna, I now stand corrected.
I can still listen to MDNA from time to time, but I can't stand RH.
Apart from Ghostown and Devil Prayer, I don't listen to any music from it.
I don't even know the lyrics from the other songs and I know all the lyrics from all previous albums.
So yes, for me, RH is awful!

[jio]

Nah, "Rebel Heart "is better than "MDNA". Problem is it is way too long and doesn't feel like an album at all, whereas "MDNA" does.

[KEY9481]

Rebel Heart's tracklisting is what caused me to abandon it very early. It did not flow well, at all.
Once reorganised, the tracks were shining more on their own, and the album sounded cohesive and strong.

[spiritboy]

RH is awful. It says a lot when most of the demos are much better than album versions.

[beredy]

Although initially I said RH was way better than mdna, I now stand corrected.
I can still listen to MDNA from time to time, but I can't stand RH.
Apart from Ghostown and Devil Prayer, I don't listen to any music from it.
I don't even know the lyrics from the other songs and I know all the lyrics from all previous albums.
So yes, for me, RH is awful!

Thank you!

Nah, "Rebel Heart "is better than "MDNA". Problem is it is way too long and doesn't feel like an album at all, whereas "MDNA" does.

Next!

[AlphaMale]

Rebel Heart's tracklisting is what caused me to abandon it very early. It did not flow well, at all.
Once reorganised, the tracks were shining more on their own, and the album sounded cohesive and strong.

I did that and ended up with 2 songs! Ghosttown and Devil Pray.

I can't stand BodyShop the song. Not even its live version, Wich is very unusual.

[BodyShop]

I can't stand BodyShop the song. Not even its live version, Wich is very unusual.

Me too
The user as well

[jio]

I did that and ended up with 2 songs! Ghosttown and Devil Pray.

"Body Shop" is a great idea that (I agree) somehow doesn't work on record or live. But still... how can you just end up with 2 songs???? I can name at least 10 fab songs from in there

[AlphaMale]

"Body Shop" is a great idea that (I agree) somehow doesn't work on record or live. But still... how can you just end up with 2 songs???? I can name at least 10 fab songs from in there

Fab songs on RH??? NO WAY!!!
Not even Ghosttown that everybody praises is all that! It's a boring album...
MDNA has some of her strongest and clever lyrics ever and it's sound was very much innovative at times. RH is just... meh!
That lead single that goes nowhere...
Well we do have Bitch I'm Madonna, I forgot about that one, that it's by far her best song in there. And that says a lot!

[jio]

"Messiah" is up there with the best songs of her career. How come you forgot it?

[AlphaMale]

"Messiah" is up there with the best songs of her career. How come you forgot it?

It's a recycled melody from before, "I've heard it all before", so no, it's not one of her best...

[CandyShop]

Inside Out Beautiful Scar Devil Pray Messiah Addicted Borrowed Times they are all amazing tracks.

Don’t like Ghosttown

Love Body Shop

[jio]

It's a recycled melody from before, "I've heard it all before", so no, it's not one of her best...

recycled melody from which song?????

[Erotica]

Both MDNa and Rebel Heart have many good songs for me.

If you cut bad songs from MDNA like Give me all your luvin or Turn up the radio, then you get a solid album.

[Angeman]

I listen to RH weekly. MDNA maybe every 6 months. I will say though that MDNA seems more like a traditional Madonna album.

[BodyShop]

Inside Out Beautiful Scar Messiah Addicted Borrowed Times they are all amazing tracks.

Agree with with all of those.
Plus Wash All Over Me and Joan Of Arc.
I love VVV and the title track.
Overall,it's not one of my favorite albums,far from that,but still...

[BodyShop]

MDNA has some of her strongest and clever lyrics ever

Tbh,I think that's the case when it comes to RH.
The only lyrics I like in MDNA are Love Spent,I F' Up and,to an extent,Best Friend.

Superstar makes me feel a second hand embarrassment for her. Those lyrics could've been written by a Junior High kid.
Some Girls,GGG,GMAYL, Turn Up The Radio,I'm A Sinner, Beautiful Killer, all cringe to death lyrics...
Let's not even mention B'Day song.
I'm only judging lyrics here,not songs per se.