The Mariah Carey Discography Rate - Album Averages

[TheRealest]

Like I said, DFAU doesn’t sound like WBT

[TheRealest]

One & Only is skippable, Joy Ride is nice and has great vocals...

After Tonight was clearly a My All rehash but it’s a damn good one. Beautiful song with beautiful vocals

Loverboy (Remix) was CLEARLY the best version of the song! Issa bop and contains the iconic shade
“Hate on me much as you want to
You can't do what the **** I do
Bitches be emulatin' me daily (Daily)
Hate on me much as you want to
You can't be who the **** I be
Bitches be imitatin' me, baby”

Sent From Up Above is a cute bop and probably her most chill song up to that point

I honestly hate that version of O Holy Night because it was unnecessary af and I can’t stand hearing her voice from 2 different eras on the same song. Original version is surperior.

Standing O was a bop, and one of the best on MOAIA (which isn’t saying much) and Your Girl is also a nice retro bop

UTS (Drifting Remix) is a real gem! Doesn’t too the feeling of the original but it’s amazing how she can rework the same song and give it a different feeling. Daydream greatness

Now....

Ill Be Lovin U Long Time sounded like a summer smash waiting to happen and I hate it got released after the era was already killed but its still a bop!

I’m That Chick is so breezy and cool and I love the lyrics! Makes you want to go smoke a blunt and turn the music up. Definitely fit the theme of the album and her life around that time period.

why is Mesmerized even in the top 100...? Overrated af among fans... literally nothing special about this. I said what I said.
Same with Here We Go Around Again... cute but a lil too dated for me sis. Issa no.

Don’t Forget About Us is another good one. I’ve always loved the lyrics and how she raps the bridge then unleashes that iconic whistle. Who else can make a song like that? Never understood the WBT companions because it’s it’s own song and sounds nothing like the other

A No No is cute and catchy but it lacks something. Idk

GTFO was fresh for her and overall a bop but no way should it have been released first for such an important image reconstruction that was going on in 2018 for MC.

[Leo]

So 162 songs are already out, all 201-332 and 71-100. And here is the recap by era:

	Total	201-332	101-200	1-100	Remaining
MARIAH CAREY	12	3		1	8
EMOTIONS	14	4			10
MUSIC BOX	16	5		1	10
MERRY CHRISTMAS	15	5			10
DAYDREAM	19	3		2	14
BUTTERFLY	21	4		3	14
RAINBOW	19	7		2	10
GLITTER	14	5			9
CHARMBRACELET	20	13		1	6
THE EMANCIPATION OF MIMI	29	14		3	12
E=MC2	18	7		4	7
MEMOIRS OF AN IMPERFECT ANGEL	19	9		2	8
MERRY CHRISTMAS II YOU	13	6		1	6
ME. I AM MARIAH THE ELUSIVE CHANTEUSE	19	8		2	9
CAUTION	11	2		4	5
THE RARITIES	16	2		2	12
OTHER	57	35		2	20

Charmbracelet and Emancipation had the most casualties in the 201+ positions, but TEOM had many remixes in those positions!
Emotions, Christmas and Glitter are still awaiting to get a Top100... I think the first two have obvious ones in the upper part of the rank, but is Glitter getting a Top100?

[Leo]

BUBBLING UNDER Part XII: 200 to 191





A popular single, a HOT AS FIRE Remix, her best original christmas tune and an ULTIMATE 11 leaving next!


.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.


#200
Jesus Born On This Day
Avg: 6.83

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK)
Lowest Rate: (whoawhoa)


#199
We're Not Making Love Anymore (with Michael Bolton)
Avg: 6.83

Highest Rate: 10 (InfoFromAus)
Lowest Rate: 4 (JSparksFan, Rawiri, mattsky)


#198
You're So Cold
Avg: 6.85

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay, DNK)
Lowest Rate: 3 (Leo)


#197
There's Got to Be a Way
Avg: 6.86

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK)
Lowest Rate: 3 (sYair)


#196
Subtle Invitation
Avg: 6.86

Ultimate 11: leoavalon
Highest Rate: 10 (DNK, Marchum)
Lowest Rate: 1 (RayRay)


#195
O Come All Ye Faithful / Hallelujah Chorus (ft. Patricia Carey)
Avg: 6.86

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay, freeme, DNK)
Lowest Rate: 2 (Leo)


#194
Honey (ft. Mase & THE LOX) [Bad Boy Remix]
Avg: 6.88

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK, Marchum)
Lowest Rate: 1 (RayRay)


#193
Want You (ft. Eric Benet)
Avg: 6.89

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK)
Lowest Rate: 2 (Leo)


#192
All My Life
Avg: 6.89

Highest Rate: 10 (freeme, Marchum)
Lowest Rate: 4 (Wayne, JSparksFan)


#191
Never Forget You
Avg: 6.90

Highest Rate: 9 (bm08)
Lowest Rate: 4 (monarcbutterfly)

[Goldmoney]

Kween can’t stand her mother these days.

[mattsky]

Some nice tracks but not my favorites

[Leo]

Jesus Born On This Day at #200 is heartbreaking.... if you love One Child so much to place it in the top100, I just cannot digest that JEsus is barely entering the top200...

There's Got to Be a Way is a song I would skip but that lately gain some attention from my side.

Subtle Invitation was an instant fav when Charmbracelet appeared, but I don't go there now. Still I think the song is good and it's too low here.

O Come All Ye Faithful / Hallelujah Chorus (ft. Patricia Carey) is probably her worst christams tune for me, with or without PAt.

Honey (ft. Mase & THE LOX) [Bad Boy Remix] is too low! I do understand that maybe it's Honey + rappers, and those kind of remixes may not add too much to the song, but this one is F I R E.

All My Life always sounded to me like a Luis Miguel song. The structure, the backing vocals, it's very reminiscent of his style of pop songs.

[bm08]

Of these, You'e So Cold and Never Forget You deserve more. You're So Cold is her most impressive introduction to a song. NFY is perhaps her most soulful. These rates are very low for both!

[Leo]

​​​​

A GOAT appears in this next batch, it surely will ignite G$'s fire... Also dropping: a remix that outperformed it's original version and a beloved album track.
.
.
.
.
.
.



#70



We Belong Together (Remix) [ft. Jadakiss & Styles P]
Avg:8.00

Ultimate 11s: Goldmoney
Highest Score: 10 (Leo, InfoFromAus, TomerMC, Marchum)
Lowest Score: 5 (skylynx, freeme, Wayne)



#69



Triumphant (Vintage Throwback Mix)
Avg:8.05

Highest Score: 10 (RayRay, Goldmoney, InfoFromAus, Thriller)
Lowest Score:: 5 (freeme)


#68



Fourth of July
Avg: 8.05

Highest Score: 10 (RayRay, freeme, TomerMC, DNK, Marchum)
Lowest Score:: 5 (monarcbutterfly)

[Leo]

Sorry we've failed you G$

Spoiler!

RayRay, whoawhoa, Goldmoney, bm08, skylynx, sjm, InfoFromAus, JSparksFan, freeme, Tomer_MC, spiritboy, monarcbutterfly, DNK, RedSimba, Rawiri James, Marchum, Thriller, leoavalon, sYair, mattsky, Wayne, matthew_dixon, Leo

[Goldmoney]

To be fair, I thot it was going to crash out in the 100s because a lot of the rap remixes were falling, and if that happened I would have been the most infuriated I’ve ever been in my life. However, I am still...
The best remix of all time to the best song of all time. GOAT as a club banger - who even comes up with absurd ideas like that? But what we got was earth shattering, beautiful, and life-affirming! Jada and Styles killed it, Kween completely turned the rap from the original on its head, rivaling some of the best MCs of all time. Besides this abhorrent placement, it’s the biggest injustice ever that we never got a video for it!

[Goldmoney]

Oh my f’n god, FLOWRIAH SPITRIAH HOLY ISH WTF SHE MURDERED THAT RAP LIVE!

[sYair]

Leo sorry to be that person again but the score for TGTBAW seems out of place!!

And I didn't notice it just because I gave the lowest score, I just like to look at numbers very closely

[bm08]

Typo. Fixed!

[mattsky]

The Triumphant remixes are dope!

[bm08]

4th of July is just okay. I think it’s lowkey overrated tbh. It’s a good album track at best.

[InfoFromAus]

It's difficult for me to know what to think at this stage, because there are almost 70 songs to go... though I'm sure I'll be shocked when some other songs emerge ahead of the WBT remix.

That track is just... so good. How can you not?!

It must have had a bunch of 8s, cause I can't imagine it getting anything lower (except for that low score of 5 which should be an anomaly).

This is shaping to be interesting/infuriating.

[Wayne]

I love the Vintage remix of Triumphant and Fourth of July is also pretty good.

[Thriller]

That remix of Triumphant slays so many remixes! It’s up there with her 90s mixes.

[bm08]

Come to think of it, it’s quite surprising that a Triumphant remix is in the top 100! That’s quite good!!0

[Leo]

We Belong Together (Remix) [ft. Jadakiss & Styles P] as a ONE TIME ONLY, here is the full list of points:
11: 1
10: 4
9: 3
8: 5
7: 1
6: 2
5: 3
4-0: 0


It's also important to remember the scale:
10 - GOAT, above perfection!
9 - Perfection
8 - Almost perfect!
7 - Very good!
6 - Good one!
5 - Okay, I enjoy when it comes
4 - Sometimes I skip it...
3 - I skip it most of the times, sorry
2 - I deleted it from my library
1 - Erase from planet earth

So all consider it Okay, I enjoy it when it comes or better.

I do see that it should have been all 8s and above but well, diversity rules the world!

Triumphant, great remix, in fact I always loved it more than the original. I feel this should have been actually the song whith the rapers version the remix...

4th of july is lovely and deserves this placing. I would have been surprised to see it higher though.

[Goldmoney]

K so that’s 14 more names added to my black book.

[bm08]

BUBBLING UNDER Part XIII: 190 to 181





Lots of album tracks that range from hip hop to soul, from Christmas to dance. Album tracks take the plunge!


.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.


#190
Triumphant (Get 'Em) ft. Rick Ross & Meek Mill
Avg: 6.90

Highest Rate: 10 (JSparksFan)
Lowest Rate: 5 (DNK, monarcbutterfly, mattsky)


#189
Bliss
Avg: 6.90

Highest Rate: 10 (freeme, DNK, RedSimba)
Lowest Rate: 2 (Wayne)


#188
Love Hangover / Heartbreaker (Live)
Avg: 6.92

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay, Marchum)
Lowest Rate: 2 (skylynx)


#187
Jesus Oh What A Wonderful Child
Avg: 6.94

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay)
Lowest Rate: 4 (Marchum)


#186
Say Somethin' (David Morales Radio Edit)
Avg: 6.94

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK, RayRay, Marchum)
Lowest Rate: 2 Leo)

#185
Portrait
Avg: 6.95

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK)
Lowest Rate: 2 (Wayne)


#184
Cruise Control (ft. Damian Marley)
Avg: 6.95

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay)
Lowest Rate: 3 (mattsky, sjm)


#183
Just To Hold You Once Again
Avg: 6.95

Highest Rate: 10 (Wayne)
Lowest Rate: 4 (monarcbutterfly)


#182
Didn't Mean To Turn You On
Avg: 6.95

Highest Rate: 10 (DNK, Marchum, mattsky)
Lowest Rate: 2 (Wayne)


#181
100%
Avg: 6.95

Highest Rate: 10 (RayRay, Marchum, DNK)
Lowest Rate: 3 (mattsky)

[Goldmoney]

Original Triumphant is actually pretty dope. I think they were trying to go for another IKWYW moment - with a bunch a of rappers overwhelming the song and Kween doing the hook + a cute lil verse at the end. But it just didn’t connect at all sadly.

[mattsky]

I love, love, LOVE her version of Didn't Mean To Turn You On. It's always on my workout playlist.

[bm08]

100% is a bit overrated.

Cruise Control is one of my favourites - a standout in her discography!