Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Mariah Carey Discography Rate - Album Averages

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • InfoFromAus
    replied
    Originally posted by bm08 View Post
    Here we go...cracking open the top 10

    The songs that are left randomised:

    Always Be My Baby
    All I Want For Christmas Is You
    We Belong Together
    The Roof (Back In Time)
    Fantasy
    My All
    Vision of Love
    I dare not make predictions, but I have a feeling that ABMB will rank higher than WBT.

    Vision of Love will be in the top 5.

    My All will be top 3.

    Leave a comment:


  • ilearnedfromthebest
    replied
    More important is music quality, not buying 5 copies of album just for make album #1, it's then fake success.

    Leave a comment:


  • InfoFromAus
    replied
    Originally posted by JSparksFan View Post
    Okay, since this is about to finish, lemme try to catch up:

    Underneath the Stars - overrated.
    Anytime You Need a Friend - this has grown on me so much. One of her finest ever.
    O Holy Night - among her top 5 vocal performances.

    Caution - her sexiest song. Honey can eat its heart out.

    Honey - I love the remixes more than anything.

    Leave a comment:


  • JSparksFan
    replied
    Okay, since this is about to finish, lemme try to catch up:

    Without You - one of her finest covers, and definitely her most critically-acclaimed cover. I love it.
    I Still Believe - suspiciously high. It's cute tho.
    Slipping Away - hmm...the lambs like this one this much?
    Obsessed - higher than I thought it'd be, but I love the energy of this song. So diva.
    Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) - good song.
    Touch My Body - also higher than I thought it'd be.
    Out Here on My Own - hmm...
    Can't Let Go - I like this - classic melody.
    Whenever You Call - such a pretty melody.
    Love Takes Time - simple but beautiful.
    Can't Take That Away (Mariah's Theme) - ooh, this is an all-time favourite of mine!
    Close My Eyes - mature.
    Underneath the Stars - overrated.
    Emotions - ooh, a tough one to sing at karaoke!
    Dreamlover - summer bop!
    It's Like That - hmm...I think this is fuelled by the comeback energy of that era.
    Anytime You Need a Friend - this has grown on me so much. One of her finest ever.
    Betcha Gon' Know (The Prologue) - whoa, this is high...but I can't say it's undeservedly high. Great songwriting.
    Fly Like a Bird - fantastic song, but I'm happy it isn't higher. It's adequately ranked.
    Everything Fades Away - hmm...this is high, but it is a good song.
    When You Believe - whew! This song has quelled my anxiety in some truly high-pressure, high-stress moments.
    Lead the Way - that final note tho!
    Butterfly - this song is without flaws.
    Breakdown - it's grown on me, but it's higher than I'd have ranked it.
    Heartbreaker - fun video.
    O Holy Night - among her top 5 vocal performances.
    Caution - her sexiest song. Honey can eat its heart out.
    Giving Me Life - classic, rich melody.
    #Beautiful - bleh at this being so high. Uber overrated.
    Honey - I love the remixes more than anything.

    Leave a comment:


  • InfoFromAus
    replied
    Originally posted by bm08 View Post

    Interesting observation!

    It had the highest number of 9 rates (10).

    Highest number of 9 rates:
    - #Beautiful (10) [plus one 9.5]
    - Caution (9)
    - Melt Away (9)
    - Emotions (8)
    - Dreamlover (8)
    - Make It Happen (8)

    That is quite interesting indeed.
    I like interrogating numbers... which may seem odd to some haha.

    I was one of the 9s for #B. In fact, I was responsible for a few of those 9s.

    Leave a comment:


  • matthew_dixon
    replied
    Wow - the top 16 so far is "O Holy Night" (which I ranked top) and aside from that songs that either I don't know, or ones I ranked singlehandedly lowest of anyone!

    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    Originally posted by InfoFromAus View Post
    What an incredible top 7!

    Also, surprised that #B rated so highly given the scores... I'm guessing it has the fewest 10s out of any of the top 10 songs.
    It must have had a lot of 9s.
    Interesting observation!

    It had the highest number of 9 rates (10).

    Highest number of 9 rates:
    - #Beautiful (10) [plus one 9.5]
    - Caution (9)
    - Melt Away (9)
    - Emotions (8)
    - Dreamlover (8)
    - Make It Happen (8)

    Leave a comment:


  • nemospence
    replied
    GML- The Caution album is well-represented inside the top ten with this song. A good R&B song. Initially, this was my favorite song from the album. But The Distance and Caution are giving me life more now.

    #B- I love the melody of this song. I 'm not sure about the sound quality though. Well she produced this song during her American Idol stint as a judge. Maybe she wasn't 100 per cent dedicated on this one. I wasn't excited when this song came out. Because it kinda stole the attention away from the AI contestants. It would be a better idea if she gave this song to the winner and get heaps of praises as a co-writer. I'm sure she thought about it too. And it would have ranked higher than #15?

    H- Yeah, this song can represent the Butterfly album inside the top ten, I'm okay with that, really. But I would have preferred the song that bears the name of the album. Thank You.

    Leave a comment:


  • InfoFromAus
    replied
    What an incredible top 7!

    Also, surprised that #B rated so highly given the scores... I'm guessing it has the fewest 10s out of any of the top 10 songs.
    It must have had a lot of 9s.

    Leave a comment:


  • Thriller
    replied
    Honey is such a groove, surprised I didn’t rate it 10.

    #Beautiful was her last UK hit

    Leave a comment:


  • spiritboy
    replied
    Honey brings out my inner slut, i love that bop so much.

    Leave a comment:


  • mattsky
    replied
    Honey is perfection. The video is iconic. Giving Me Life is everything, but I'm surprised it's made the top 10. #Beautiful is a great summer song.

    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    Here we go...cracking open the top 10





    The songs that are left randomised:



    Always Be My Baby
    All I Want For Christmas Is You
    We Belong Together
    The Roof (Back In Time)
    Fantasy
    My All
    Vision of Love

    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    #08





    Honey
    Rated: 9.30



    High Scores (10): whoawhoa, Goldmoney, skylynx, sjm, Leo, freeme, TomerMC, spiritboy, monarcbutterfly, DNK, Rawiri James, Marchum, mattsky
    Low Scores (5): matthew_dixon






    UKMIX Fan Comments:

    Originally posted by LongingHeart View Post
    it hardly gets any better than this, Honey is a MASTERPIECE!
    Everything about it is just perfect.
    Originally posted by DOSSOME View Post
    The video =LEGENDARY
    The song =FANTASTIC
    Originally posted by BlueScorpion View Post
    I've been addicted to "Honey" from day 1. The video could only make me love the song even more.

    That jump to the pool in high heels alone >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Originally posted by TheRealest View Post
    Re: Mariah Carey - Honey

    This is 90s Perfection. An angelic voice singing over a real hip hop beat. An (eternal) bop.

    Mariah. A legend.

    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    #09





    #Beautiful
    Rated: 9.26



    High Scores (10): Goldmoney, Leo, freeme, spiritboy, DNK, Marchum, mattsky, Wayne
    Low Scores (7): Rawiri James






    UKMIX Fan Comments:

    Originally posted by SawyerHewitt View Post

    Anyway, #Beautiful was quality and really was a smash.
    Originally posted by stevyy View Post

    #Beautiful :: 10/10 :: We all know it by now. Perfect Summer song.
    Originally posted by naughtynae View Post

    #Beautiful - Whats not been said? Lush, summer groove a welcome return to form.


    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    #10





    Giving Me Life
    Rated: 9.25


    Ultimate 11: bm08
    High Scores (10): whoawhoa, sjm, JSparksFan, TomerMC, spiritboy, monarcbutterfly, DNK, RedSimba, Marchum, mattsky
    Low Scores (5): RayRay






    UKMIX Fan Comments:

    Originally posted by ferrero View Post
    Giving me life is still giving me life
    Originally posted by LotsOfLove View Post
    Giving me life is something else. She really SNAPPED with that one. A masterpiece.




    Leave a comment:


  • Thriller
    replied
    Heartbreaker bops hard and has the iconic video.

    Leave a comment:


  • bm08
    replied
    Originally posted by InfoFromAus View Post
    The Breakdown video was something else.

    Honey was great - a fun, energetic and entertaining video, but Breakdown was class all the way.
    Which makes it insane that the video almost never happened.

    Leave a comment:


  • InfoFromAus
    replied
    The Breakdown video was something else.

    Honey was great - a fun, energetic and entertaining video, but Breakdown was class all the way.

    Leave a comment:


  • nemospence
    replied
    Breakdown- I like that this song added some variety to the Butterfly album. I appreciate this song when I just listen to it rather than watching the music video which takes my attention away from the song.

    Heartbreaker- This is her song that makes me want to dance. It started with a great hook. The music video was just as entertaining. Might I just add though? The guy was really cute.

    Caution- One of the best songs from the critically acclaimed album Caution . It became one of her underrated songs as well because it didn't receive a single treatment. It didn't see the light of day.
    Last edited by nemospence; Fri June 25, 2021, 00:13.

    Leave a comment:


  • skylynx
    replied
    It's a shame this song did not crack the Top 10. It was the best song on Caution and perhaps her most progressive song in a long time. This song is better than GML.

    Wayne - "I will hunt you down".



    Originally posted by bm08 View Post
    #11





    Caution
    Rated: 9.25



    High Scores (10): RayRay, whoawhoa, skylynx, JSparksFan, spiritboy, monarcbutterfly, DNK, Marchum, mattsky
    Low Scores (6): Wayne






    UKMIX Fan Comments:








    Leave a comment:


  • mattsky
    replied
    My bets:

    10 Giving Me Life
    9 #Beautiful
    8 My All
    7 Always Be My Baby
    6 Honey
    5 Vision of Love
    4 The Roof
    3 Fantasy
    2 WBT
    1 ALWFCIY


    I'd live The Roof to win but it's unlikely

    Leave a comment:


  • monarcbutterfly
    replied
    I do think O’ Holy Night is the greatest vocal performance Mariah has given in the studio. For me it’s just perfect and glad to see it placing so high.
    I adore Heartbreaker and have some wonderful memories of that specific time in ‘99.
    Caution is a whole vibe and not surprised it’s so high.

    Bring on the top 10

    Leave a comment:


  • Goldmoney
    replied
    10 Giving Me Life
    9 The Roof
    8 My All
    7 Always Be My Baby
    6 #Beautiful
    5 Vision of Love
    4 Honey
    3 Fantasy
    2 Xmas GOAT
    1 GOAT

    Let’s go.

    Leave a comment:


  • Goldmoney
    replied
    Those positions should be reversed tbh.

    Breakdown laid down the blueprint for GOAT.

    Despite Jay-Z’s verse and Clue’s ratchet adlibs, Heartbreaker is one of her gheyest ever releases!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X