beredy wrote:The video has 0 replay value. In 2018 it's better to do a lyric video than a video like this.
There’s nothing wrong with the video. It’s definitely a step up for her. Her last few (excluding GTFO) have been tacky.. at least this is quite arty and elegant
Actually GTFO is more suited for YT than With You. You actually want a video that has something extra in it to give it a replay value. There's nothing "wrong" with WY video as is, it's just basic and feels more like a video you do for a 4th or 5th single when you don't want to waste money and film it in one afternoon. As is - this won't get that many views on YT.
LotsOfLove wrote:I don’t know what the heck you want from Mariah. Y’all should be happy she loves her fans and still releases music cos really she wouldn’t even need to do that anymore.
Just because somebody doesn't have to do it, does not make them immune to criticism when they actually do something.
Personally GTFO and With You are the strongest singles Mariah has delivered in ages. I won't actively go and listen to them, but I won't skip the radio or playlist if they come on (like I would with most of her songs/singles). Also #justiceformigrate